I can't get this image out of my head.
Thomas Rowlandson, The English Dance of Death, ca. 1815-1817.
All year, although it's more than a year now, I keep coming back to this image. Death sitting on the world, time running out, it's an image that has spoken to me outside of the original historical context. Death's Dance keeps on, while the current world just pretends it does not exist. Death's face- is it sad? Resigned? Disappointed? Just tired?
I've been thinking a lot about death as disruption.
I haven't heard from someone in a while, sent a card, never heard back, which is unusual. My paranoid, anxious brain has of course imagined they are dead. I'm well aware that I could just email or call and see. But it got me thinking- I'm not family, so maybe their actual family wouldn't know to call me. Maybe to them I'm just another name in the address book. Am I in the address book? If it's younger folks, maybe they lack ability to know how to track people down? If it was unexpected, as so much death is these days, maybe there was no will, no plan, no instructions for getting into digital accounts.
I know many of us have lost people, continue to needlessly lose people, have heard of colleagues or acquaintances who are gone. I wonder how many others we just have not heard about yet. I wonder at how grief is lurking, waiting for us. I wonder how this all gets stretched out, delayed, even as so many people continue to die.
I wonder about people who are not important enough, famous enough, for anyone even to know. A thought I've had quite a lot the last five years is how little I matter in the grand scheme of things. I could die today and no one would know. Eventually the SPCA would probably get a welfare check done in a few weeks when I didn't communicate about the foster kittehs. The head of summer school might check in if I didn't make my class live in a couple of weeks. I have a will, a lawyer to settle all my accounts, distribute money to mushing charities. But who else would know? Nobody. The real kicker? Who would notice or care? Again, nobody. I've spent a good chunk of the last five years making my peace with that.
8 June was my five year semi-colon anniversary. It was ten years on Valentine's Day since Mom died. I've spent most of those ten years thinking about death. At first my thoughts about death were odd, disjointed. I spent weeks, months, sobbing uncontrollably, the littlest thing setting me off. Desperately wanting her to come back. I still have dreams where she has come back to life and I don't know how to tell anyone. Immediately after her death people were kind, they reached out. But I learned there's a short shelf life before people move on. The world moved on and I was just stuck. Frozen. Unable to do anything. What few casual friends I had stopped checking in. Calling. Anything. Many made contact months and years later and just ignored that she had died, not even mentioning it, or mentioning it casually, oh I heard, I'm sorry.
Yet her death continued to disrupt my life.
My life was disrupted when it was decided that everything of hers had to go. Boxed up, cleaned up, given away. She was a pack rat so it was a lot. But it was also things I wasn't ready for.
Still people kept moving. And I was still not. The easiest way I could explain it is that life stopped that day. Everything hit pause. Then in like one of those weird movie scenes, I stayed still, in place, and everything else gradually (and not so gradually) sped up around me, kept moving, leaving me behind. I moved, I finished my PhD, I changed jobs, I moved again, I changed jobs again, and yet, still stuck.
I read Swedish Death Cleaning, I pared down most of what I owned to the minimum I could get by on (mostly, my graphic tee collection is still a lot), not wanting to leave behind a mess for others. I don't set emergency contacts. I have a lawyer as my executor, they will donate house contents to Goodwill, sell the house, consolidate goods, give lump sums to charities, close accounts. There will nothing for anyone not paid for it to deal with. I've made it all as easy as I can.
I look at the Christmas decorations Mom loved, that I no longer put out, they just sit in the garage, and I wonder what the point is. I am not married. I have no one to pass them down to. There is no one to remember, to know the stories behind the chubby cheeked chipmunk, or the brass 1st year ornaments. There is no one to show these things to, share them with. They just sit there. They will sit in those Tupperware, and when others open them it will be totally devoid of their context.
The photos in bins have all been digitized, as the photo albums fell apart years ago. But I don't know who most of the people are in them. I don't know when they were taken. I don't know what the event was, who the party was for, why we were there, if they matter. There is no longer anyone left to tell me. For the stories I do know, there is no one for me to tell. They're just-there.
I think a lot of people who die by suicide do it because they just don't see the point anymore. At some point it just becomes too much, there's a tipping point, and even if they were able to NOT for days, years, before, it seems like sometimes the energy supply just runs out and you just stop one day. Maybe there's a finite amount of energy, of fight we can hold. Maybe some people have that amount restored by outside things, I think many probably don't.
Usually it is the deaths of others that are the disruption to our lives. How the grief, the loss, comes in waves, hitting you even when you think you're fine, how it comes out of nowhere, and all of a sudden you're stuck again. How the disruption affects everything, your ability to do day to day things, shower, dress, eat, function. How the idea of the global death, the ignorant, senseless, uncaring attitudes have resulted in so much needless death, living with the knowledge about the kind of careless, easy evil that takes. How does anyone move forward after all of this? How do we forgive so many people who enabled this? How do we look at them? Work with them? How do we make space for the ongoing greif and loss that will define us for the rest of our lives?
I used to believe that there was something after this life. I wasn't sure what, but I believed in something. I stopped believing after Mom died. I just can't believe that there's a world where I would not have felt anything. The thing I have come to realize the last ten years is that death is meaningless. Death is nothing. There is no greater purpose, there is no good death, lives do not matter because people miss you or you did something. Lives matter. That's it. I have had a reason to make my life matter, to keep breathing every day with no external reason. I have had to decide to keep going each day in the face of the reality that it does not matter in a single instance whether or not I do.
I've been reading a lot about premodern desert Ammas. I've always loved the idea of strong, educated, dedicated women just saying "fuck this shit" to institutions and frameworks that don't have a space for them, and just leave. To make and forge new lives. One thing that strikes me again and again when reading about early Church Ammas and Abbas is that so many of the nuns, the monks, had to acknowledge their insignificance. The role pride plays in so much of our lives. That we think we're special, that we matter, that we're important. But the simple truth is most of us are not. Most of us live lives that don't matter at all, or matter to a very small circle of others. Surprisingly, I find this knowledge comforting. I don't have to find a big reason every day to keep going. The small work, the little tasks, the insignificant to just about everyone things, these are my contributions. They don't add up to anything. They're not anything that will have major influences on anything or anyone. They just are. They're daily work. It's work that if I didn't tell anyone, no one would ever know about it. There are no ripples in the pond, there is no collective impact.
Somehow, this is easier for me. I no longer fight to make my mark, matter, be noticed. The more time that goes by, the more I retreat, pare down, step away. It makes it really easy to say no to things. No, I don't have to waste time making someone I knew in high school feel better. No, I don't have to internalize your characyerization of me. No, I don't have to silently accept your racist, misogyny, bigotry. No, I don't have to try, to exert energy, to waste time. The phrase "I don't care" does not always mean you are incapable of caring, sometimes it is just that you have chosen not to care about that thing. Because there is finite energy. A finite amount of stuff. And I choose not to waste it.
I think a lot about what I'd leave behind. Notebooks that have occupied so much time and energy will just be binned. So now I write just for me. Photos I spent time scanning, caring for, sit in boxes. The few that are out are out because it means something for me to see them every day. The toys, the knick knacks in my office, are fun, but they serve no other purpose outside of me, my daily life and use. My teaching is not big, flashy, known outside of the small communities I've taught in. My scholarship is not fancy, noticed, big. It is huymbling and empowering to know that my life does not matter except for how it matters to me. To build a life with no external encouragement, importance is not easy. Our world is designed for families, couples, groups, collectives. Everything is harder if you are not part of these things. From small things like food portions at the store, to big things like no one to take you home from the hospital. But it is possible. It's harder. Western Anglo culture doesn't except lone figures. But it can be done.
We may collectively lose, grieve, experience the disruptions of death. We may collectively make space for dealing with these things. We may collectively acknowledge them. I hope we do, but I don't know how we deal with the sheer scope of it. I don't know what comes next. Maybe we're all just traumatized for the rest of our natural lives. Maybe we all individually have to just find a way through in order to be able to GET through. Maybe everyone has to find a way to construct their lives to expect, accept, and survive the continuous disruptions because there is never going to be an end.
I don't know.
I don't believe in the after anymore. Just this.